As expected, the NHL has ushered in the 2004-05 hockey season with a lockout. The finger-pointing and press releases will now continue through possibly January, possibly the rest of the season. Also as expected, both sides are saying “We’re offering everything but the kitchen sink, but the other side is refusing to negotiate.”
In a general sense, I’m on the side of the owners in this dispute. The NHL is the weakest of the four “major” sports. Its television contract is next to worthless. Its overall revenue is small. But the players are demanding salaries on par with the NFL or the NBA. Granted, equal blame can be laid at the owners’ feet for preaching fiscal responsibility and then turning around and offering $5 million a year to a 3rd-line defenseman, which drives up salaries. But it’s the player’s union that needs to ask themselves if they want their average player to “only” make a mil a year or so, or if they want the league to fold.
The biggest black mark on the player’s side is their union’s refusal to entertain a salary cap. Tying salaries to revenues has been very successful for the NBA and the NFL – it’s allowed those leagues to thrive, leveled out the playing field to enable small-market teams to compete, and provided stability between the league and the union. The players’ stubborn refusal to consider the good a salary cap could do for the volitale finances of the NHL is foolish and counterproductive.
But the fans now have to face a season without hockey. For newer fans in newer markets, like those in Raleigh, it could undo a lot of what the NHL has built in the area. The Hurricanes have built a strong following here, even in spite of the crappy product that was put on the ice for the past two seasons. But if you cancel the season, you run the risk of the fans getting into another routine that doesn’t involve heading to the RBC a few nights a week, or watching John Forslund on Fox Sports Net. Even a sport as entrenched in the American culture as baseball had to fight and claw its way back from the ill will generated by its labor troubles a few years back. The NHL doesn’t have that luxury.
My white Hurricanes jersey, with the “ESA First Game” patch and the player signatures, hangs in the closet. Who knows when I’ll get to put it on again?